Microsoft 365 security audit checklist: what to verify every quarter
Most Microsoft 365 incidents in small organizations come from a short list of gaps: accounts without MFA, legacy authentication left on, spoofable domains, mail quietly forwarded out, and logs nobody checked. A quarterly audit that walks through the same controls each time catches drift before an attacker does.
How to run a quarterly audit
- Use read-only access. The Global Reader role can view most admin-center settings without being able to change them; add Security Reader for the Microsoft Defender portal.
- Know your licenses. Conditional Access needs Microsoft Entra ID P1. Privileged Identity Management and risk-based policies need P2 (or Entra ID Governance). Safe Links and Safe Attachments need Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 or higher, which is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium.
- Record evidence, not memory. For each control write down where you checked, what you saw, and the date.
- Score and prioritize. Fix high-impact identity and email gaps first.
The high-priority controls
These are the controls we mark High priority because they block the most common attack paths. Our full checklist has 50.
| ID | Control | Licensing |
|---|---|---|
| ID-01 | MFA is required for all users (Conditional Access policy or security defaults). | Conditional Access needs Entra ID P1; security defaults are free. |
| ID-02 | Admin roles require phishing-resistant MFA (Conditional Access authentication strength). | Entra ID P1. |
| ID-03 | Legacy authentication is blocked for all users. | Entra ID P1 for Conditional Access; security defaults are free. |
| ID-04 | At least two emergency access (break-glass) accounts exist: cloud-only (*.onmicrosoft.com), phishing-resistant auth, permanent active Global Administrator, excluded from blocking Conditional Access policies. | All tenants. |
| ID-05 | Global Administrator count is small (Microsoft recommends fewer than five). | All tenants. |
| ID-09 | User consent to applications is restricted (verified publishers / low-risk permissions only) and an admin consent workflow is enabled. | All tenants. |
| EX-01 | SPF TXT record is published for every domain that sends mail. | All tenants. |
| EX-02 | DKIM signing is enabled for each custom domain. | All tenants. |
| EX-03 | DMARC record is published and has a plan to move from p=none to quarantine or reject. | All tenants. |
| EX-04 | Automatic external forwarding is blocked or tightly controlled in the outbound spam policy, with documented exceptions. | All tenants. |
| EX-05 | Preset security policies (Standard or Strict) or equivalent anti-phishing, anti-spam and anti-malware policies are applied. | EOP for all; some protections need Defender for Office 365. |
| DC-01 | SharePoint and OneDrive external sharing is set to the most restrictive level that the business accepts. | All tenants. |
| DV-01 | Compliance policies are assigned for every platform in use (Windows, macOS, iOS/iPadOS, Android). | Intune license. |
| DV-03 | Conditional Access requires a compliant (or hybrid-joined) device for access to corporate data. | Entra ID P1 + Intune. |
| DV-04 | Disk encryption (BitLocker / FileVault) is enforced and recovery keys are escrowed. | Intune license. |
| DV-06 | Update rings / feature update policies are assigned and devices run supported OS versions. | Intune license. |
| DV-08 | Antivirus / endpoint protection is onboarded with tamper protection on. | Depends on plan. |
| LM-01 | Audit log ingestion is on and an audit search returns recent events. | All tenants. |
| GV-02 | A documented offboarding process disables sign-in, revokes sessions, and removes licenses, devices and shared access. | All tenants. |
Identity: where most breaches start
MFA for everyone. Either security defaults (free) or Conditional Access policies (Entra ID P1) should require MFA for all users. Don't stop at "most users": service accounts and shared mailboxes with sign-in enabled are frequent gaps.
Phishing-resistant MFA for admins. Adversary-in-the-middle phishing kits can relay push or code-based MFA. Conditional Access authentication strengths let you require passkeys (FIDO2) or certificate-based authentication for admin roles.
Block legacy authentication. Older protocols can't perform modern MFA. Check sign-in logs for legacy clients before blocking so you know what will break.
Emergency access accounts. Microsoft recommends two or more cloud-only emergency accounts on the *.onmicrosoft.com domain, protected with phishing-resistant authentication, excluded from Conditional Access policies that block sign-in, and monitored with alerts. See our break-glass account guide.
Keep Global Administrators few. Microsoft recommends fewer than five. Use role-specific roles such as User Administrator or Exchange Administrator for daily work.
Restrict app consent. Consent phishing tricks users into granting a malicious app access to mail and files. Limit user consent to verified publishers and low-risk permissions, and turn on the admin consent workflow.
Email: spoofing and silent forwarding
Publish SPF for every sending domain, enable DKIM for custom domains, and publish a DMARC record with a plan to move from p=none to quarantine or reject. Our free DMARC record generator builds the TXT record for you.
Block automatic external forwarding in the outbound anti-spam policy and document exceptions. Attackers who take over a mailbox often add an inbox rule that forwards everything to an outside address.
Sharing, devices and logs
- Set SharePoint and OneDrive external sharing to the most restrictive level the business accepts, and make "Specific people" the default link type.
- Require compliant devices through Conditional Access once Intune compliance policies are in place, and set devices with no compliance policy to be marked not compliant.
- Confirm the unified audit log is working by running a search for the last 24 hours. Audit (Standard) keeps records for 180 days; longer retention needs Audit (Premium) or export.
Make it repeatable
Save each quarter's results, compare scores, and report the top three open risks. Our Tenant Security Audit Kit packages all 50 controls with where-to-verify paths, licensing notes and automatic scoring in one Excel workbook.